The Gym Contract Problem: What This Study Reveals About Commitment, Identity, and Irrational Persistence

Imagine this: you pay for a gym membership in January, full of motivation. By April, you’ve stopped going. But you don’t cancel. Month after month, the money leaves your account. You don’t use the gym. You barely think about it.

Still, you don’t cancel.

This simple situation became the foundation of a groundbreaking study in behavioral economics known as “The Gym Membership Contract Study” by Taly Reich and Ayelet Fishbach.

What they found is more than just a quirk of consumer behavior. It’s a window into how we handle regret, identity, and the invisible mental costs of walking away.

This article is an exploration of the full theory behind the study, the psychological mechanisms involved, and how this strange little human habit connects to personal productivity, career decisions, team dynamics, and the way organizations manage failure. It’s not just about gyms. It’s about how we cling to the illusion of progress because quitting feels worse than wasting.

What Was the Study, Really?

In a series of clever experiments, Reich and Fishbach tested how people behaved when they were asked to make a second decision about a past commitment. The key question: Would people cancel a gym membership they weren’t using?

The twist was that researchers manipulated how the original commitment was framed:

In one version, participants were reminded that they had chosen the plan.
In another, they were told it was randomly assigned.

People were significantly more likely to stick with a bad decision when they had chosen it themselves.

Why? Because walking away from a decision we made feels like admitting failure. And we’re wired to avoid that pain, even at a cost.

This is what they called “the cost of cancelling”: not financial, but psychological. The gym contract became a symbol of an intention, a self-image, a story. Cancelling meant admitting the story didn’t play out.

Let’s Break It Down: What’s Happening in Our Heads

The study uncovers several powerful forces at play:

1. Sunk Cost Fallacy: You’ve already spent money or time, so you keep going—even if continuing makes no sense. But that’s not rational. Rational decisions should ignore past costs and focus only on future value. But emotionally, it’s hard to “let go” of what’s already invested.

2. Identity Commitment: When we make a choice, we often attach identity to it. “I’m the kind of person who goes to the gym.” Letting go of the choice can feel like letting go of a part of ourselves.

3. Regret Aversion: Quitting triggers the acknowledgment that we were wrong. That feels bad. So we prefer quiet inertia over explicit failure.

4. Illusion of Progress: Keeping the contract gives us a symbolic sense that change is still possible. We trick ourselves: “Maybe next week I’ll go.” That illusion can be more comforting than the truth.

This gym story is not just about fitness. It mirrors behavior across multiple domains. Let’s explore some of them.

In Project Management: Why Teams Don’t Kill Bad Projects

Just like a gym membership, a failing project often continues because someone once believed in it. Teams double down on bad ideas because stopping would mean explaining sunk time, budget, and credibility.

You often hear:

“We’ve already invested six months.”
“We’re too far along to stop now.”
“Let’s try one more sprint.”

The psychology is the same: stopping is framed as failure, so we avoid it, even when stopping would save time and money.

The best project managers learn how to create a culture that doesn’t shame quitting. They build in decision checkpoints, celebrate pivots, and separate identity from original plans.

In Agile Teams: When Rituals Lose Their Edge

Think of Agile ceremonies like stand-ups, reviews, and retrospectives. They’re meant to create reflection and change. But often, they turn into symbolic performances—soft commitments.

People show up. They say the thing. They move on.

It’s the gym membership all over again. A team feels like it’s being Agile because it goes through the motions. But without real feedback and course correction, those rituals are just theater.

To fix this, teams need to bring consequences and learning back into the routine. Stand-ups should lead to real changes. Retros should produce tracked experiments. Reviews should influence decisions.

In Productivity: The Illusion of Change Through Planning

Buying a productivity app, building a Notion dashboard, blocking your calendar, even buying a journal—these actions feel like progress. But unless they change your actual behavior, they’re soft commitments.

This is the personal gym trap: “I planned the change, so I must be on track.”

But plans are not action. Routines are not growth. You only escape this trap by setting hard commitments: deadlines, review points, and feedback loops.

A good practice is asking weekly: “What did I stop doing this week?” If the answer is always “nothing,” then you’re carrying dead commitments.

In Career Decisions: Staying Too Long Because You Once Believed

Sometimes we stay in the wrong job, role, or industry far too long. Why? Because leaving would mean admitting that our earlier choice was wrong. The psychological cost of quitting can outweigh the real-world cost of staying stuck.

This is especially true for high-achievers who link self-worth to consistency or loyalty. But real growth comes from course correction, not stubbornness.

Career pivots feel like failure from the inside. From the outside, they often look like wisdom.

The Quiet Cost of Keeping Dead Decisions Alive

One thing the study hints at, but that deserves more attention, is the mental and emotional energy required to maintain dead commitments. Every month, you see the gym fee, and you flinch. You avoid thinking about it. That avoidance accumulates as stress.

These “open loops” drain you. They clutter your focus. They make it harder to move forward.

Cutting them—even just acknowledging them—can be profoundly freeing.

So What Do We Do About It?

This is not just about willpower. It’s about designing environments and habits that help us avoid soft traps. Here’s how to get started:

1. Create Default Off-Ramps: Add natural checkpoints to commitments: “I’ll review this in 3 months and cancel if not used.”

2. Track What You Quit: Keep a “stopped doing” list. Celebrate smart quitting.

3. Separate Self From Decision: You are not your past choices. You are your current behavior.

4. Share Exit Stories: Normalize public reflection on things that didn’t work. Make it okay to say “we changed course.”

5. Use Feedback as a Trigger: Tie rituals to outcomes. If your routine isn’t producing real change, ask why.

Final Thought: Be Wary of Soft Comforts

The study by Reich and Fishbach shows us something deep: that our minds prefer the comfort of continuity, even if it means wasting energy and avoiding reality. We carry this bias across every part of life.

But the strongest people and teams learn to separate progress from ritual. They stop worshiping effort and start rewarding reflection. They let go not because it’s easy, but because they know staying stuck is worse.

So next time you see that old commitment you’re no longer using, a gym card, a dead project, a routine with no impact, don’t feel guilty. Just ask:

“Is this helping me grow? Or is it helping me avoid regret?”

If it’s the second, you know what to do.

Let it go.

I am incredibly grateful that you have taken the time to read this post.

Please, check my premium newsletters:

Please, check also my Book Notes!

Support my work by sharing my content with your network using the sharing buttons below.

Want to show your support and appreciation tangibly?

Creating these posts takes time, effort, and lots of coffee, but it’s totally worth it!

If you’d like to show some support and help keep me energized for the next one, buying me a virtual coffee is a simple (and friendly!) way to do it.

Do you want to get new content in your Email?

Do you want to check previous Book Notes?

Do you want to check previous Articles?

Check my main categories of content below:

Navigate between the many topics covered in this website:

Support my work by sharing my content with your network using the sharing buttons below.

Want to show your support tangibly? A virtual coffee is a small but nice way to show your appreciation and give me the extra energy to keep crafting valuable content! Pay me a coffee: